2018 amicus brief Best Of community Education Features free speech Fundraising Games Headline Homepage International Legal legal action LGBTQ media News Blog publications

Comic Book Legal Defense Fund 2018: A Year in Review


Wanting again at 2018, a yr that was crammed with challenges and victories, it’s straightforward to see that the entrance strains of free expression are nonetheless underneath assault all too steadily. Because of the beneficiant help of members, readers, and followers,  Comic Book Legal Defense Fund was capable of face the challenges head-on and struggle for First Modification rights of readers all throughout the nation. Take a look at a number of the greatest elements of 2018, and think about making a tax-deductible donation at the moment to assist be part of the continued battle without spending a dime expression in 2019!

CBLDF took a part of a number of essential courtroom instances this yr, together with submitting amicus briefs, to supply professional recommendation in two excessive profile First Modification instances.
Within the first, CBLDF filed an amicus temporary with 9 different media organizations, asking the New York Courtroom of Appeals to reject actress Lindsey Lohan’s and former Mob Wives star Karen Gravano’s invitation to broaden the state’s proper of publicity regulation by broadening New York Civil Rights Regulation Part 51. The temporary said that the “plaintiffs’ proposed reading of this state’s privacy statute would have a profoundly chilling effect on free speech.” That studying would endanger a variety of comics, together with works of nonfiction, fiction, and satire. Each Lohan’s and Gravano’s lawsuits towards Take Two Interactive claimed that their likeness and personas have been used to create fictional characters in the favored online game Grand Theft Auto V, which violated their proper to privateness. If Lohan and Gravano had succeeded in increasing the idea of privateness to incorporate potential cartoon likenesses of actual individuals, nonfiction comics and satire comics would have been in danger for fixed censorship. Fortunately the courtroom determined Lohan and Gravano had no case, and dismissed it.
David Pulphus painting
CBLDF contributed an amicus temporary with a numerous group of free speech nonprofits and humanities advocacy organizations after the congressional architect eliminated a controversial paintings from an exhibition following directions from then speaker of the home Paul Ryan. The portray, by David Pulphus, depicted pigs in police uniforms, threatening anthropomorphized wolves protesting police brutality. The portray was eliminated beneath the guise that artwork hanging in Congress, counted as Congressional speech. The.  Temporary posited that “The visual arts are omnipresent in public libraries, universities, and government buildings. Particularly in the case of student artists, governments often sponsor or support such displays. If an artist’s individual expression in his or her art ‘could be passed off as government speech by simply affixing a government seal of approval, government could silence or muffle the expression of disfavored viewpoints.’ Matal v. Tam, 137 S. Ct. 1744, 1758 (2017). That is precisely what happened here. Moreover, contests or public displays of art would likely become tantamount to contests to convey messages that curry favor with the government, which is more characteristic of totalitarian regimes than our democracy.”


close be heard!

2018 was a fantastic yr for brand spanking new free assets advocating the freedoms of the First Modification. In a yr crammed with residents using their proper to peaceably assemble and “petition the Government for a redress of grievances,” tens of millions of American college students stood up for themselves and spoke out towards the gun violence chopping the lives fo their friends far too brief. Prematurely of the protests scheduled throughout the nation, Comic Book Legal Defense Fund and Nationwide Coalition Towards Censorship teamed up with cartoonist Kai Texel to create Be Heard! – a free comedian designed to stipulate greatest practices, attainable dangers, and supply further free assets to assist youngsters assert their rights to speech, protest, meeting, and petition! Take a look at http://cbldf.org/beheard to learn, share, and obtain your copy in the present day!

Comics Start Here Front Page


Making certain the liberty to learn begins with making certain the perfect entry to books attainable. With that in thoughts Comic Book Legal Defense Fund partnered with graduate college students at College of Washington iSchool to determine how everybody discovered comedian books (or didn’t) in their native libraries. Comics – Begin Right here! is the results of these findings! A free useful resource designed to reply attainable questions librarians might have about comics and manga, talk about shelving methods, and patron engagement. To learn, obtain, and share a replica of Comics – Begin Right here!, together with an inventory of free on-line assets, take a look at http://cbldf.org/library
Read Banned Comics Cover

When contemplating the huge variety of books in the world, it’s clear that proportionally comics are probably the most ceaselessly challenged and banned – so CBLDF created a visible information that helps you determine, perceive, and shield them! Learn Banned Comics is a free useful resource that delves into comics which are challenged, tips on how to report and battle censorship, programming concepts, and extra tricks to make a celebration of Banned Books Week in your group! Uncover the books ceaselessly dealing with censorship. Hear from the creators themselves as they speak about their very own experiences having work banned, together with Neil Gaiman, Raina Telgemeier, G. Willow Wilson, and extra. Discover enjoyable and academic concepts for internet hosting Banned Books Week occasions in your retailer, faculty, or library! To learn, share,  and obtain your copy of Learn Banned Comics take a look at http://cbldf.org/read-banned-comics

funhomeBecause of very important donations made in 2017, CBLDF was capable of mobilize shortly and shield everybody’s freedom to learn in 2018. Two essential victories each got here following assaults on LGBTQ literature.

The primary assault arrived in New Jersey, when two mother and father determined that the award-winning graphic novel Enjoyable Residence was unacceptable as a result of “the sexually explicit nature.” The guide was assigned to varied senior English sections this previous spring, and one of many mother and father, Steve DiSturco, needed it faraway from the curriculum earlier than his baby turned a senior in the autumn.

In an e mail to New Jersey’s Echoes~Sentinel, Superintendent Elizabeth Jewett stated that whereas she understood the considerations each mother and father had, the work was chosen with cautious consideration. “The curriculum was expanded to include a broad range of literature to reach all students, not just works that portray traditional gender and sexual identities. The expansion of the English curriculum is in alignment with the strategic plan and is the result of a two-year research process which included professional development for the English department staff.”

CBLDF and the Youngsters Proper to Learn Challenge drafted a letter of help to encourage the Superintendent of Watchung Hills Regional Excessive Faculty to face behind their curriculum. The letter addressed to Superintendent Elizabeth Jewett discusses authorized precedents set that help the First Modification proper of scholars and gives further assist with the problem if the varsity wants it.

“We perceive that the guide – which was just lately added to your 12th grade curriculum after a two-year evaluate – incorporates illustrations that some mother and father have objected to, prompting a evaluate per Watchung Hills District Coverage 2240.

We write to supply our help as you carry out this assessment. We urge you to base your selections on pedagogical motives, fairly than yielding to ideologically motivated pressures from some teams or mother and father.”

Additionally included with the letter, was a replica of the CBLDF Dialogue Information for academics utilizing Enjoyable House in their lecture rooms.

Along with CBLDF, the letter was signed by Nationwide Coalition Towards Censorship, American Library Affiliation’s Workplace for Mental Freedom, Nationwide Council of Academics of English, American Booksellers for Free Expression.


Then again in September, CBLDF discovered of an try and ban a number of books, together with the LGBTQ themed graphic novels My Lesbian Expertise With Loneliness by Nagata Kabi and Queer: A Graphic Historical past by Meg John-Barker and Julia Scheele from the Rumford Public Library in Maine. CBLDF mobilized on social media to induce all Rumford space residents to attend the general public library board assembly and defend everybody proper to learn freely.
The try and ban the books got here from three native church leaders who noticed the library’s Banned Books Week show, and determined with out an ironic bone in their our bodies, to attempt to ban the titles of which they didn’t approve. The problem referred to as out Nagata Kabi’s manga as “immodest and inappropriate for a public setting” on the idea of its cowl alone. The letter difficult the show about referred to as out different books like Two Boys Kissing for “promoting homosexuality.” In accordance with a Fb publish by native resident Katrina Ray-Saulis, one of many letter’s signers “has verbally expressed that he would like to pursue the destruction of all books regarding homosexuality in the library.”

CBLDF  was among the many first to reply in help for the library, alongside Nationwide Coalition Towards Censorship and the American Library Affiliation’s Workplace for Mental Freedom. Because of the far-reaching help of CBLDF followers who shared the story and the stalwart and outspoken locals who attended the library assembly and fought for the liberty to show books that cowl the pursuits and tales of many various voices, the problem was shot down and the show stayed standing. “The freedom to read is expanded when citizens have the right to make up their own minds,”  stated CBLDF Government Director Charles Brownstein concerning the choice, including “We commend the board of the Rumford library for respecting their citizens and upholding their rights.”

If you wish to assist with victories like these in 2019, contemplate making a donation at the moment. Your beneficiant help helps CBLDF prolong recommendation and assets when comics are challenged everywhere in the nation, in addition to develop new methods to battle for freedom of expression daily. Whether or not you turn out to be a card-carrying member of CBLDF or snag free speech merch in our Reward Zone, each greenback donated to CBLDF helps additional the struggle free of charge speech in the approaching yr.


Tags: 2018, amicus temporary, better of, free speech, authorized motion, lgbtq, publications