Academy Apprentice/Audit Blogs Animal Rights Apprentice Thesis Elephant Academy elephant magazine Enlightened Society ethical sheep shearing Games Green organic wool PETA Right Livelihood sensationalism sheep shearing vegan wool

What Vegans are getting Wrong about Wool.

What Vegans are getting Wrong about Wool.

Wool isn’t all the time black or white—it’s a thousand shades of gray.

Let’s minimize to the wool and have an open and trustworthy speak about sheep, their fleece, and the ethics therein.

When my daughter and I moved to Portland sight unseen and never understanding one single soul, we took the recommendation of all nice sages and got here with the intention to like our neighbor and see what occurred.

At our first Thanksgiving away from our household, we chatted with our new neighbor Stacey, and she or he advised us about the superpowers of wool. Wool is antimicrobial, hyper-absorbent, hearth retardant, hypoallergenic, biodegradable, and wicks moisture. Superpowers certainly.

We started discussing concepts for do-it-yourself Christmas presents for my household, when Stacey first advised me about dryer balls; I had by no means heard of them. The subsequent day she introduced over scraps of wool, and we made our first “WoolyBalls” for my mother.

Once we went again to Colorado for Christmas, we used them time and again, they usually actually labored! My favourite reminiscence as a toddler is heat laundry poured over me whereas my mother folded and I watched cartoons. I can solely think about how far more enjoyable it will have been with WoolyBalls combined in.

We have been having household dinner earlier than heading house to Portland when the thought for our enterprise was born.

“Honesty is for the most part less profitable than dishonesty.” ~ Plato

After three years within the wool enterprise, it has come to my consideration that animal rights organizations will do and say simply about something to get consideration for his or her trigger.

Having been inundated with false info all through my life, I’ve develop into delicate to unfaithful particulars imparted by any individual or group that doesn’t place honesty and integrity over consideration and falsified public relations.

False info and sensational tales geared towards disabling individuals and their industries is now a staple character inside our privileged, first world society.

Within the Elephant Journal article, “Wool is Cruel,” it seems Individuals for the Moral Remedy of Animals (PETA) employed knowledgeable publicist to persuade folks that sheep are typically harm and maimed within the strategy of wool manufacturing. It’s fairly clear the writer’s intention is to elicit emotion, principally anger and disgust, towards the wool business. There isn’t any thoughts paid to those that work ethically inside the business, nor are there proposed options.

I’m conscious of the injury manufacturing unit and industrial farming is inflicting the surroundings. I ended consuming meat and dairy because of this.

That stated, life is just not black and white; there are all the time shades of gray. When accepting that harvesting wool ought to be lumped into the unethical remedy of animals, we fall prey to ignorance.

It’s necessary to make clear that the topic of this text is wool, not sheep pelts or meat.

To ensure that me to ethically proceed in my enterprise, I wanted to know the reality about the ethical and environmental nature of wool manufacturing. Here’s what I’ve discovered.

Shrek and Shrek 2, Australian and New Zealand merino sheep, have been each misplaced from their flock and located years later. Each sheep individually had over 60 kilos of fleece once they have been discovered.

To place this in perspective, every sheep carried sufficient wool to supply 1,600 dryer balls or 5 queen-size merino blankets.

Sheep have a mean weight of 160 kilos; their regular physique temperature is 103 levels. On common, one merino sheep produces eight to 10 kilos of wool a yr. Neither Shrek or Shrek 2 would have made it for much longer. The fleece they carried would ultimately maintain them from strolling and subsequently consuming, and they might have died.

So if sheep have to be shorn, why don’t moral vegans condone wool?

Dan Gutzman, a tenured international wool purchaser responded to “Wool is Cruel,” saying, “this article describes antiquated growing and shearing processes, even prior to the publish date. The author sensationalized one or two instances of human error over the history of industry growth. What industry doesn’t make mistakes?”

Dan clarifies: “Flystrike is an action of fly larvae eating their way into the sheep and is an act of nature that is specific to Australia. Mulesing is the act of removing the top two layers of skin on the back of the legs near the sheep’s rear so to preserve the sheep and their wool.”

When this course of is completed, it cuts the sheep; that is the method PETA and vegans rightfully oppose. Mulesing has been outlawed in New Zealand; nevertheless, Australia nonetheless employs mulesing practices. It is very important make clear that there isn’t a different nation on the planet utilizing mulesing practices, as Australia and New Zealand are the one locations on the planet with that exact fly.

Animal rights organizations lead us to consider this course of occurs to all sheep, in all areas of the world.

The Save Motion, an animal rights group with 530 chapters worldwide, pays witness to livestock earlier than and through the slaughter course of. Throughout a go to to their sales space at Northwest Vegan Pageant, one among their head activists informed us,“wool is an unnecessary commodity, and sheep overall do not need to be shorn.”

Based on the American Sheep Business (ASI), solely three to 5 % of all domesticated sheep worldwide don’t have to be shorn. There are roughly 60 million sheep in america and one billion worldwide. The sheep that don’t want shearing are referred to as Dorper and have hair as an alternative of fleece.

Domesticated sheep have been part of the human tradition since 11,000 to 9,000 B.C. Mesopotamia, and have been the second tamed animal after canine. Sheep have been bred for hundreds of years, their wool perfected over the ages.

Moreover, the Berry Modification (USC, Title 10, Part 2533a) requires america Division of Protection procure all their wool from home sources earlier than any wool is procured abroad. Because it seems, wool is among the most essential commodities for the USA Authorities, because it’s utilized in army uniforms and bedding.

So far as I can see, there isn’t any moral distinction between a purebred canine and a purebred sheep. Presently, there are greater than 1,000 distinct breeds of sheep on the earth and 350 breeds of canine. It’s straightforward to attribute the massive distinction between canine and sheep to the monetary worth of fleece.

Nonetheless, I’m perplexed by the wrong info introduced by PETA and The Save Motion, as they declare to help the moral and type remedy of animals. From what I’ve discovered, it truly requires a reprimand within the class of faux information.

“Honesty is the first chapter in the book of wisdom.” ~ Thomas Jefferson

Fact: sheep have to be shorn, each for his or her well being and their happiness.

Wool manufacturing in Oregon is world-renowned; all the wool my firm makes use of in our merchandise is grown within the U.S. and has high-ranking certifications in environmental and agricultural security.

In October 2017, PETA positioned a billboard in downtown Portland, Oregon; it displayed an image of a nude Alicia Silverstone, stating she would somewhat go bare than put on wool. The commercial was a transparent shot on the Oregon wool business.

Though the commercial is gorgeous, it’s also unethical, sensational propaganda. The reality of the USA wool business is way from what PETA introduced with this billboard.

Most nations throughout the globe have made in depth changes in insurance policies to make sure their wool is procured ethically. If PETA needs to tackle the unethical remedy of sheep, they need to set their sights on the nations that don’t make use of laws, corresponding to Australia and China.

China is probably the most outstanding wool purchaser on the earth, they usually buy 74 % of Australia’s provide.

In response to the PETA billboard, Jacob Valentine of Darkside Shearing, a fifth era sheepshearer from Crabtree, Oregon, revealed a collection of nude photographs of his personal. His is a vital voice within the dialog about the moral nature of wool.

The intention of Jacob’s nude shearing was to convey consideration to the shearer’s required demeanor when shearing. To ensure that Jacob to shear a 160-pound sheep, bare, all elements uncovered, he would most definitely have to know what he’s doing and provides quite a lot of look after the sheep to save lots of himself from any bodily hurt.

It is very important perceive that shearers don’t receives a commission in the event that they reduce or harm the sheep. In the USA, shearers are recognized to extend their costs if the sheep they are shearing are not correctly cared for by the farmer.

In response to Kirsten Holbo, the proprietor of Iron Water Ranch in Corvallis, Oregon, “the fleece that sells has no breaks in the fibres, and when a sheep is harmed or cut in the shearing process, the fleece produced becomes less valuable and both sheep and wool tainted. Quite frankly, it pays for the farmer to have shearers that care.”

Once I met Jacob at a sheepshearing and fibre sale, the shearing course of occurred in roughly 4 minutes, and, though Jacob was absolutely clothed throughout my go to, I might see how the method could possibly be harmful for each the sheep and the shearer. In accordance with Jacob, sheepshearing is the second most troublesome job on the earth, subsequent to Bolivian tin mining.

“If wool shrinks when you wash it, why don’t sheep get smaller when it rains?” ~ Ron Bracklin

Wool is a superpower. It has turn into clear: sheep not solely have to share their wool, however they need to.

It was exceptional to observe the convenience and style of Jacob and Wendy, the sheep he labored with. It delivered to thoughts a Vogue article that highlighted ladies shearers, referred to as “Women of Wool,” through which shearing is likened to a “beautiful dance—fluid and clean.”

Honestly, the shearing with Jacob went smoother and was a lot faster than my canine Bernice’s grooming appointments. There was no whining, just one small kick, and no wrestle. Clearly, sheep submit—Wendy simply submitted. My high-maintenance princess canine, Bernice, fights extra when she will get her nails carried out than Wendy did when she was shorn.

“Sweet mercy is nobility’s true badge.” ~ William Shakespeare

It appears on the matter of wool, PETA’s place is demonstrated by rebellious acts of emotionalism; gaining consideration is their mission, ruffling feathers their energy.

As a glass half full sort of individual, I want to recommend PETA reinforce the true mission of wool and start to help variety and acutely aware shearing practices.

In line with Maria Rooney, a lifelong nomadic Shepherd from Silverton, Oregon, “Sheep are docile creatures and are dependent on their caretakers; it’s a truly symbiotic relationship between sheep and farmer.” A sheep’s want for a shepherd is just not an idiom.

Maria additionally described the shearing course of like “a mama cat picking her baby by the tuft. As soon as the shearer positions the sheep, the sheep relax fully and the shearing process is seamless.”

I want Bernice would do this.

Moreover, it isn’t simply religious and non secular knowledge that teaches people to be the pure stewards of the earth; it’s a organic reality. Tending and caring for sheep, together with the moral apply of shearing, isn’t just phenomenal, it’s an natural necessity.

Since sheep have to be shorn, we are chargeable for shearing them, with care.

The easiest way to help the moral care of sheep is to purchase wool from locations and companies that use wool from nations with good wool practices.

This can be a clear name for an elevated degree of clear integrity; fabricated information and sensational tales have to be deserted. The reality have to be informed and proven.

There’s an apparent discrepancy within the vegan argument towards wool. This can be a dialog that have to be began if vegans are to develop into a revered voice and truly have an effect on the change we have to see on the planet.

Sheep and their wool are a present to humanity; their care is in our palms. Wool is just not a black or white choice, it’s 1,000 shades of gray, wrapping us in heat and guardianship, defending us from the tough parts of life. Because the wool protects us, so should we shield the sheep, the supply of our wool. It is so simple as being an conscious human.

Love sheep and love their wool: that is what nature meant.



window.fbAsyncInit = perform()
appId : ‘920662958027189’,
cookie : true,
xfbml : true,
model : ‘v2.9’



(perform(d, s, id)
var js, fjs = d.getElementsByTagName(s)[0];
if (d.getElementById(id)) return;
js = d.createElement(s); = id;
js.src = “”;
fjs.parentNode.insertBefore(js, fjs);
(doc, ‘script’, ‘facebook-jssdk’)



// if(typeof mixpanel != ‘undefined’)
// $(‘.modal-login-form type enter.user_login’).focus(perform()
// mixpanel.monitor(“Login Email focus”, “Form ID”: $(‘.modal-login-form type’).attr(‘class’));
// )
// $(‘.modal-login-form type enter.user_pass’).focus(perform()
// mixpanel.monitor(“Login Password focus”, “Form ID”: $(‘.modal-login-form type’).attr(‘class’));
// )

$(‘.fb-login’).click on(perform(e)

$(‘.ej-login-container-wrapper .disabled-overlay’).present();
var MPEventTitle = ‘Fb Login’;
var MPProperties = ;
MPProperties.technique = “Facebook”;
var publication = $(this).mother or father().discover(‘type enter[identify=”newsletter”]:checked’).size ? 1 : zero;

var formWrapper = $(this).mum or dad();‘#login_error’).take away();

var redirecting = false;
var redirect = typeof $(this).attr(‘data-redirect’) != ‘undefined’ ? $(this).attr(‘data-redirect’) : ‘/?p=1787720’;
MPProperties.FacebookResponse = response.standing;
if (response.standing === ‘related’)
FB.api(‘/me’, fields: ‘e-mail’ ,
if(typeof meResponse.error != ‘undefined’)
MPProperties.userLookup = “Undefined Error”;
$(‘.ej-login-container-wrapper .disabled-overlay’).cover();

We are having hassle connecting to Fb. There’s nothing you are able to do. Fb is having issues. We apologize on their behalf. Within the meantime, be happy to attach utilizing your e mail handle under.

else if(typeof meResponse.e-mail != ‘undefined’)
var user_source = $(‘enter[identify=”user_source”]’, formWrapper).val();
if($(‘type’, formWrapper).attr(‘class’))
user_source = $(‘type’, formWrapper).attr(‘class’);

var distinct_id = “”;
if(typeof mixpanel != ‘undefined’)
distinct_id = mixpanel.get_distinct_id();

var knowledge =
motion: ‘create_user_from_fb’,
e mail: meResponse.e-mail,
mp_distinct_id: distinct_id,
user_source: user_source,
publication: publication,
user_source: user_source,
technique: ‘Fb’,

technique: ‘POST’,
url: ‘’,
knowledge: knowledge,
timeout: 13000,
success: perform(ajaxResponse)
if(ajaxResponse != “fail”)
redirecting = true;
window.location.href = redirect;
MPProperties.userLookup = “New User Creation Failed”;
$(‘.ej-login-container-wrapper .disabled-overlay’).cover();

error: perform(e)
if(typeof mixpanel != ‘undefined’)
mixpanel.monitor(‘Login Timeout’, “Login Type”: “Facebook”);


Oops, one thing received tousled on our finish. Please reload the web page and provides it one other shot, or attempt logging in right here.


MPProperties.userLookup = “Could not authenticate”;
$(‘.ej-login-container-wrapper .disabled-overlay’).disguise();

Couldn’t authenticate you by way of Fb. Please attempt once more, or use your e-mail handle as an alternative to create an account.



Couldn’t authenticate you by way of Fb. Please attempt once more, or use your e-mail handle as an alternative to create an account.


if(typeof mixpanel != ‘undefined’)
mixpanel.monitor(MPEventTitle, MPProperties);

scope: ‘public_profile,e mail’